I thought I would give my personal reefing experience. It is still a work in progress, but I was in need of improvement in my reefing.
Jim above has described the best method with lines led aft. It will cost you some dough for blocks, cleats and lines.
However, I came up with a $17 half-way solution.
A few days ago in 10 to 15, I was alone and practicing in a wide channel. My reefing was a disaster as it always was. I managed to get it done but sloppy and 3 to 4 minutes before it was complete. That included chasing reefing lines that I am too embarressed to explain where I had them. They flapped in the breeze as I grabbed for them.....
After studying this forum and books at the library, I made a list of all the things I needed. I liked what this website had to say
http://tritonclass.org/articles/linesaft/reef.html
When I took my sketch to WM and priced it all out including lines I was about $200. I said to the WM rep I would think about it.
I went back to the boat and did think about it and practice various things until I came up with the solution I will describe here. I used a spare $17 Swivel Block and some spare line as my sole investment in reefing.
Here is my procedure, refering to the pictures below.
1. Luff mainsail and TIGHTEN TOPPING LIFT. If you don't have your topping lift on, the boom will fall on your head. Ask why I know this.... Also, loosen boom vang.
2. Release mainsail from cockpit cam cleat to premarked position (magic marker on main halyard.)
3. Use downhaul to help bring down main to premarked reef position. (Downhaul is just a line connected at the head of the mainsail right where the main halyard is connected and then run down the mast to a block and then to the cockpit.)
4. So far, I have not left the cockpit.
5. Carefully go to the mast and hook short line in the reefing tack eyelet to the rams horn hook at mast near where boom connects to gooseneck.
6. Haul the reefing line that is routed from the reefing clew eyelet, around a Harken block slightly aft of the eyelet on the boom (hooked the swivel to the mainsheet bail) thru the boom vang bail, using it as a fairlead.
7. When tight, run reef line under same rams horn and then cleat it off on the mast cleat above it.
8. Back to cockpit, raise mainsail tightly.
9. Tighten mainsheet, adjust topping lift, and sail away under reefed main. You can tie the reefing lines that secure the loose mainsail to the boom if you want to look neat, but you can do it when you have the chance. The boat will sail safely without tying these lines, but the loose sail may billow a bit at the boom and look bad.
suggestions welcome.
Under calm conditions at anchor I can now do the whole thing in 30 seconds. On the water sailing it takes about a minute. I still need practice. And I have caught the reefing line in the works, stopping my raising the main fully when I want to go to full main sail, so I need to practice some more with that, but I did figure out to put a stopper knot in the reefing line at the mast and run it thru the mast cleat hole so it won't come loose and flap around when uncleated
My thought on the reefing matter goes like this. It is a skill you need to have. Before you go out you should be confident you can put in a reef. I have spoken to mac sailors who have had their Macs for many years and never reefed, not even once. I agree with Rick, but only if you
want to go back in and quit sailing, the weather is predicted to go no higher than 20kts, and it is not an oncoming storm that is causing the higher winds but just a brisk sea or land breeze, and, of course have a working engine.
Why reef?
For one reason, if your motor ever fails in brisk winds, then you may be overpoweed coming back with a full mainsail. You could go to only a foresail, but what if you don't have it or can't use it? Isn't that reason enough for your safety to learn reefing?
And, secondly, I have had many hours of great sheltered water sailing in 15 to 20 kts in bays and sounds and channels where I was the only sailboat out there and a few times in the open ocean. With the mainsail reefed, I could confidently sail, tack and gybe without leaning too much because of overpowering. And I always put out a little foresail to help in tacking.
that's my 2 cents...